| Division | Best Christlike Character Award | Winner | Second Place | 3rd Place |
| 2012 Varsity Girls Volleyball |
FCS |
FHS |
ISA |
TCS |
| 2012 Middle School Girls Volleyball |
CCS |
FHS |
ISA |
CRCS |
| 2012 Varsity Girls Soccer |
HHS |
FHS |
TCS |
HHS |
| 2012 Middle School Girls Soccer |
FHS |
TCS |
CCA |
CCSHHS |
| 2012 Middle School Boys Soccer |
VAA |
ISA |
FHS |
TCS |
| 2012 Boys Flag Football |
CRCS |
CCA |
VAA |
CCS |
| 2011/12 Varsity Girls Basketball |
HHS |
FHS |
HHS |
TCS |
| 2011/12 Middle School Girls Basketball |
CCS |
CCA |
TCS |
HHS |
| 2011/12 Varsity Boys Basketball |
TCS |
CCA |
TCS |
FHS |
| 2011/12 Middle School Boys Basketball |
CCS |
TCS |
CCA |
FHS |
| 2011/12 Junior Varsity Boys Basketball |
AFA |
FHS |
TCS |
AFA |
